[matroska-general] Fw: Re: container format MPCF ( mplayer mediacontainer format )

Christian HJ Wiesner chris at matroska.org
Mon Feb 17 05:11:44 CET 2003


FYI :

"D Richard Felker III" <dalias at aerifal.cx> schrieb im Newsbeitrag
news:<20030217015543.GE180 at brightrain.aerifal.cx>...

> On Sun, Feb 16, 2003 at 11:15:47PM +0100, ChristianHJW wrote:

> >

> > "Michael Niedermayer" <michaelni at gmx.at> schrieb im Newsbeitrag

> > news:200302081955.40434.michaelni at gmx.at...

> > > currently the index at the end is required for normal files (realtime

> > streams

> > > are an exception) but the index can be repeated if the muxer wants to

> > repeat

> > > it, this IMHO doesnt add any complexity to either the muxer or demuxer
but

> > > its more flexible for thouse crazy ppl who want a few copies of the
index

> > > Michael

> >

> > matroska Team came up with the very same solution. EBML allows us to
repeat

> > the meta seek tables ( = index ) as many times as we want in the file,
but

> > we normally write it at the end.

>

> Will you please stop this already? EBML is not some sorta holy grail

> that enables you to do this, it's just one (ugly and inefficient) way

> of storing the necessary info for muxed a/v (plus lots of other junk

> that doesn't need to exist on the muxer level). It's clear that

> MPlayer developers are not interested in your matroska, so why do you

> insist on trying to promote it over and over?

>

> BTW, having a backup index at arbitrary location is useless since the

> player won't know where to find it, unless you have a header at the

> beginning pointing to the indices. Of course this is silly and just

> wastes space since the index is redundant data that can be regenerated

> if it's damaged.

>

> Rich

As robux4 was pointing out already, seems as i've messed it up again :-(
.... i just feel so helpless against this a....le, i'd wish somebody from
the mplayer users told him how arrogant and ill he is.

Christian


http://matroska.org




More information about the Matroska-general mailing list